Making Room for Surprise in Your Life
16 May
Sometimes I wonder if I’ve lost my capacity for surprise.
And I don’t mean my ability to surprise other people. I do that all the time. Just this week, for instance, my wife was surprised to find I hadn’t folded a basket of laundry for five straight days. My kids were shocked that I actually followed through on a threat to send them to their rooms. I stunned co-workers by speaking more than once at a staff meeting.
What I’m talking about is my capacity for feeling surprised. I’m so focused most of the time on getting things done and checking off lists that I don’t even have time to be caught off guard. Nor do I want to be, clinging instead to the comforting illusion that I control my domain. I couldn’t even tell you the last time something happened that left me shaking my head in wonderment – in a good way. Duke losing to Lehigh in the first round of the NCAA tournament doesn’t count.
But a few days ago that all changed.
My eight-year-old son, along with 44 other kids, received his First Communion at our church. It was a pretty elaborate ceremony, and he’d signed on for a starring role. Not having inherited his father’s extreme introversion, he volunteered to do an Old Testament reading from the altar in front of about 500 people.
A lengthy practice session at the church a few nights earlier, led by a strict Catholic school teacher, had made clear this was no simple matter. Near the beginning of the service, my son needed to walk toward the altar, hands tented in prayer, bow at a precise spot and then make his way up to the lectern. The microphone there was highly sensitive and required speaking not right into it but not too far away either. That was all before he did the actual reading from the Book of Isaiah.
When he was done, the teacher stressed, he needed to come down from the altar, wait for two girls who would be singing right after him, and meet them in front of the altar for a synchronized bow at an exact spot. Then he would come back to us. Would they also ask him to perform a complex series of black flips, analyze Chinese energy policy and solve a quadratic equation before landing in our pew, hands still tented in prayer?
On the morning of the service, we got there early and walked through it once. He seemed pretty confident. I was nervous for him but tried not to show it. When the moment came, I nudged him into action. He assumed a prayerful pose and headed toward the altar. And everything went flawlessly, like he’d practiced it all a thousand times. The bowing and the reading and the microphone. All of it. I was thrilled for him. When he returned to our pew, I couldn’t refrain from exchanging a gleeful fist bump. Check that one off the list, baby!
It wasn’t until the next morning, though, when I returned to the church with my parents for a Mother’s Day mass that it all sunk in. I watched a 40ish guy walk up to the lectern, bow, do a reading, bow again and return to his seat. And at that moment I thought with total wonderment, “I can’t believe my son, who is barely eight, did that yesterday. In front of 500 people. And perfectly, too. How did that happen?”
Over the past few days, I’ve also thought, with more concern than wonderment, “Why don’t I feel this way more often?” I doubt that it’s because more moments with the potential to surprise don’t exist in my life. I’m probably just missing them. In fact, I might have even missed the full impact of this one if I hadn’t been back in church the next day and had a few moments to reflect.
So here’s a challenge I’m setting for myself over the next week. At the end of the day, I’ll pause for a minute or two to consider whether anything surprised me. If nothing surfaces, that’s fine. It’ll be just like any other day. But if something worthwhile does bubble up, I won’t have missed it. And that can change the way you see everything.

